A proposal to designate a residential street as a city historic district has been shelved. The street, known for its wide, tree-lined layout and homes from the early 20th century, was at the center of a contentious debate. Establishing a historic district for this single street would have been a new precedent.

The argument between preservationists and opponents played out over a year, with tense meetings and online campaigns. Conflict escalated to the point of reported physical altercations between neighbors.

Further details on the proposal and its demise are available, including the vote tally and past attempts at historic designation in the area.